The second part of my research piece on ballplayers named Jay, which covers the hitters, is now up.
Here I present to you the All-Jays:
SS Jay Bell
1B Jay Kirke
CF Jay Johnstone (with Jay Payton as defensive replacement)
RF Jay Buhner
LF Jay Gibbons
DH Jay Gainer
C Jay Kleven
2B Jay Canizaro
3B Jay Ward
PR Jay Loviglio
SP Jay Hughes
SP Jay Hook (big drop-off after the ace)
SP Jay Tibbs
SP Jay Pettibon
RP Jay Baller
RP Jay Witasick
RP Jay Tessmer
SU Jay Powell
CL Jay Howell (can I get Orel Hershiser in case of a suspension?)
MGR Jay Ward (I've got enough problems without handing this team over to Jay Faatz and his 9-24 record)
Thanks to Pete Sommers at Baseball News Blog for calling attention to Part I and for getting into the spirit of things with his All-Pete team (which would probably hand the All-Jays their asses). No dice on the Pedros, Sommers, though I'll give you Guerrero because fans actually called him "Pete" for a while. The only condition is that you have to play him at third base.
